Compare
USDA Loan vs. FHA Loan
USDA and FHA are the two most flexible low-down-payment loan programs. USDA offers $0 down but has property location and income limits. FHA is 3.5% down with fewer restrictions. For buyers in eligible USDA areas, the choice is often about income limits and mortgage insurance cost.
Side-by-side comparison
| USDA Loan Zero down for eligible rural and suburban properties; income limits apply. | FHA Loan 3.5% down, government-backed, works anywhere. | |
|---|---|---|
| Minimum credit score | 640 typical | 580 (3.5% down) |
| Minimum down payment | $0 | 3.5% |
| Property location | Must be in USDA-eligible area | Any location |
| Income limits | Yes — typically ~115% of area median | None |
| Upfront fee | 1.00% guarantee fee (financed) | 1.75% UFMIP (financed) |
| Annual fee / MIP | 0.35% annual guarantee fee | Annual MIP for life of loan (most files) |
| DTI ratio | 41% total (46% with compensating factors) | Up to 56.9% with compensating factors |
| Occupancy | Primary residence only | Primary residence only |
How to choose
- USDA has significantly lower mortgage insurance cost than FHA (0.35% annual vs FHA's ~0.55%+). If you qualify for both, USDA is usually cheaper long-term.
- Property must be in a USDA-eligible area. Many Michigan communities outside metro Detroit qualify — Milan, Flushing, Fowlerville, Chelsea, parts of Livingston County. Belong Lending checks the specific address.
- Income must be under the USDA county limit (typically ~115% of area median income for household size). If your income is higher, FHA becomes the fallback.
Best for a USDA Loan
- Buyers in USDA-eligible rural or suburban Michigan communities
- Households under the USDA income limit
- Buyers who cannot put down 3.5% but have steady income
- Buyers who want the lowest possible mortgage insurance cost
Best for a FHA Loan
- Buyers in urban areas (Detroit, Ann Arbor, most metros) — not USDA-eligible
- Households above the USDA income limit
- Buyers with higher DTI who need FHA's flexibility
- Buyers who need down payment assistance layered on top
Frequently asked questions
Which is better, USDA or FHA?
If you qualify for both — meaning the property is USDA-eligible and your income is under the county limit — USDA is usually cheaper long-term because of its lower mortgage insurance cost and 0% down requirement. If the property is in a non-eligible area or your income exceeds the USDA limit, FHA becomes the better choice.
How do I know if a property is USDA-eligible?
USDA maintains a public eligibility map (eligibility.sc.egov.usda.gov). Belong Lending checks the specific address during pre-approval — many Michigan communities outside metro Detroit qualify, including Milan, Flushing, Fowlerville, and Chelsea.
What are the USDA income limits in Michigan?
USDA income limits vary by county and household size, typically topping out around 115% of the area median income. In many Michigan counties that's roughly $110,000 – $135,000 for a household of four. Belong Lending confirms the exact limit for your county.
Can I use USDA for a fixer-upper?
USDA does allow financing on existing homes that meet basic property condition standards. For homes needing significant repair, the USDA Section 502 program has limited rehab-loan options. For most rehab needs, FHA 203k is a better fit.